Skip to content

Honest TV Show Reviews, Ranked Without Hype

Find your next series through spoiler-free reviews, head-to-head ELO rankings, and honest long-form analysis from a lifelong TV enthusiast.

Featured Reviews

A fresh selection from the archive, rotated daily.

View All Reviews
Dexter: The Man Behind the Smile

Dexter: The Man Behind the Smile

A spoiler-free review of Dexter’s original eight seasons after a full rewatch: Michael C. Hall, Miami, dark humour and the effort of appearing ordinary.

Read More: Dexter: The Man Behind the Smile
The Shield: Vic Mackey's Problems Don't Stay Solved

The Shield: Vic Mackey's Problems Don't Stay Solved

The Shield combines relentless police-drama tension with accumulating consequences. Michael Chiklis and Walton Goggins lead an exceptional seven-season crime story.

Read More: The Shield: Vic Mackey's Problems Don't Stay Solved
MobLand: Tom Hardy Makes the Trouble Worth Watching

MobLand: Tom Hardy Makes the Trouble Worth Watching

Tom Hardy is MobLand's strongest reason to watch. My season-one review weighs its enjoyable gangland tension against uneven writing, accents and character logic.

Read More: MobLand: Tom Hardy Makes the Trouble Worth Watching
Absentia review: a solid thriller carried by Stana Katic

Absentia review: a solid thriller carried by Stana Katic

A spoiler-free Absentia review after all three seasons: Stana Katic carries a solid thriller with a convincing central performance and modest ambitions.

Read More: Absentia review: a solid thriller carried by Stana Katic
Gomorrah: Italy's Greatest Crime Saga

Gomorrah: Italy's Greatest Crime Saga

Gomorrah is one of my strongest recommendations: five seasons of loyalty, ambition and fear, led by Ciro and Genny. Watch it with subtitles.

Read More: Gomorrah: Italy's Greatest Crime Saga
Day 5: A Very Bad Time to Feel Tired

Day 5: A Very Bad Time to Feel Tired

The Att reviews Day 5, the survival thriller where sleep kills: an inventive what-if premise, flawed survivors and an unfinished two-season run.

Read More: Day 5: A Very Bad Time to Feel Tired

Top-Ranked TV Shows

The current top twenty from our head-to-head ELO leaderboard.

Explore the Full Rankings