Fargo: Dark Humour in a Cold World
Updated
Fargo has a wonderfully alarming idea of a quiet town. Someone can be discussing an entirely ordinary problem, in the most reasonable voice imaginable, and you find yourself wishing they would stop talking and get out of the room. The other person might be a fool. They might be considerably worse. Often it takes a while to tell.
I've watched all five seasons, and I find it genuinely difficult to pick a favourite. The cast and setting change, but the pleasure of watching people talk themselves into trouble survives every reset. Noah Hawley has taken the peculiar humour of the Coen brothers' film and made something that can sustain very different stories without losing its character. This is excellent television: funny, nasty, occasionally very strange, and far more interested in people than its body count might suggest.
A dangerous bit of encouragement
“What if you're right and they're wrong?”
I have that poster on my wall. It's a terrific line: a little permission to trust your own judgement when everyone else seems certain. Put it in Fargo, though, and the same encouragement begins to look rather less reassuring. Being convinced you are right tells us very little about whether you actually are.
That ambiguity is one of the things I like most about the show. It lets a thought sit there without attaching the correct answer. A person who feels overlooked may have a legitimate grievance; they may also be an exhausting man who believes the world owes him something. Fargo can make room for both possibilities in the same conversation. The slogan works on my wall. I would still be careful about taking advice from some of the people in this programme.
Start with Lester
The first season introduces Lester Nygaard, an insurance salesman whose small humiliations seem to have accumulated into a whole way of life. Martin Freeman is superb at the uncomfortable pauses, the swallowed objection, the face of a man trying to work out whether somebody has just insulted him. You recognise the type before the story has really started.
Then Lorne Malvo wanders into his orbit. Billy Bob Thornton barely seems to exert himself. He asks a question, waits for an answer and makes the silence feel like a threat. Plenty of screen villains announce themselves with shouting. Malvo can make a perfectly civil exchange feel like an encounter you will regret.
The pairing is a very good introduction to Fargo's sense of danger. One man is painfully conscious of what everyone thinks of him; the other appears free of that burden altogether. You don't need an elaborate criminal organisation or a map of competing factions to feel the possibilities opening up. Two people talking will do.
A fresh start worth taking
The anthology format is a real advantage. You can commit to one story rather than sign up for years of postponed answers, and each new cast has room to make its own impression. I would still start with season one and watch in release order. That gives the little connections their chance to land without turning them into homework.
The later settings change the scale as well as the clothes. The second season's 1970s crime-family world has a different energy from the third's feud between brothers. The fourth opens out into rival organisations in 1950 Kansas City; the fifth finds trouble beneath apparently ordinary domestic life. None needs to behave like an extra ten hours of Lester's story.
That variety is why choosing a favourite is so difficult. There are different pleasures rather than five attempts at the same trick. Sometimes the attraction is an individual performance, sometimes the larger criminal tangle, sometimes a conversation so peculiar that you want it to carry on even while you are wondering where on earth it is going.
Familiar faces, unfamiliar behaviour
Allison Tolman gives the first season something essential as Molly Solverson: a capable person you actually want to spend time with. Her patient attention is enjoyable in its own right. She can hear that an explanation doesn't quite work without immediately delivering a speech about it. In a show full of people performing confidence, that quiet competence matters.
The casting keeps supplying fresh attractions. Kirsten Dunst and Jesse Plemons are a fine fit for the second season's domestic unease. Ewan McGregor's two brothers give the third a particularly awkward family resemblance. Juno Temple brings determination to the fifth, opposite Jon Hamm, whose presence is a long way from Don Draper's immaculate office manners.
And season four has a particular bonus for anyone who watches Italian crime drama. Salvatore Esposito, Genny in Gomorrah, plays Gaetano Fadda, while Francesco Acquaroli, Samurai in Suburra: Blood on Rome, plays Ebal Violante. I love seeing those familiar faces here. Esposito's heavy, confrontational presence and Acquaroli's watchfulness fit the world without simply repeating their earlier characters.
The joke can wait
Fargo understands how funny an unnecessary conversation can be. Somebody wants information, somebody else insists on answering a slightly different question, and the exchange drifts into a level of detail nobody needed. The actors give these digressions the seriousness of people who have nowhere more pressing to be.
That patience makes the sudden changes in mood work. You can be enjoying someone's elaborate explanation and then notice that the person listening has stopped finding it amusing. The comedy doesn't put a protective fence around the scene. It can leave you more exposed because you have briefly relaxed.
The settings help, too. An empty road in winter looks like a place where very little happens, which is exactly what makes the thought of being stranded on it so unpleasant. The diners, modest houses and flat expanses give all that eccentric behaviour a convincingly ordinary home. This isn't a world of glamorous criminals living above everyone else. They still have to get through the weather and deal with irritating people.
Strange, but worth following
There is a streak of fable in Fargo that is worth knowing about before you start. It isn't always interested in behaving like a strictly realistic police procedural. Some conversations are deliberately heightened; some developments ask you to accept the story on its own odd terms. If you want everything reduced to a tidy explanation, that may occasionally test your patience.
For me, the strangeness belongs here. It stops the show settling into a routine of clues, suspects and the next arrest. More importantly, the ordinary people remain recognisable underneath it. Ambition, wounded pride, decency and plain stupidity supply plenty of trouble before the stranger possibilities even enter the picture.
The opening claim that this is a true story is part of that playfulness, not a reason to treat the series as a documentary. Fargo is very good at sounding matter-of-fact while quietly making you question what you have agreed to believe.
Five seasons well spent
I recommend Fargo very highly. Its intelligence doesn't come at the expense of being entertaining, and its humour doesn't require the people caught up in the trouble to stop feeling human. I can admire the construction and still simply enjoy the next awkward conversation. That is a difficult combination to sustain, and Fargo has given me five seasons of it.
For another crime anthology with a much more solemn mood, try True Detective. For patient character work and the comedy of people making their own lives worse, Better Call Saul is a natural next choice. And if the fourth season's Italian cast catches your attention, Gomorrah and Suburra are both worth following back to their own territory.
UK viewing: Check Fargo on Prime Video. UK listings checked on 11 September 2026 show Prime Video streaming; check the season and whether it is included in your subscription before paying.
Keep Reading
More Reviews You Might Like
Top 10 Gangster Shows Told From Inside the Family
Ten gangster dramas I recommend for their characters, family loyalties and criminal worlds, from The Sopranos and Gomorrah to Kin and MobLand.
Read review
Gomorrah: Italy's Greatest Crime Saga
Gomorrah is one of my strongest recommendations: five seasons of loyalty, ambition and fear, led by Ciro and Genny. Watch it with subtitles.
Read review
StartUp: Good Ideas, Very Bad Seed Money
StartUp turns a cryptocurrency venture into an engrossing Miami crime thriller, with Edi Gathegi, Otmara Marrero, Adam Brody and Martin Freeman.
Read review
Severance review: the horror of never leaving work
My spoiler-free Severance review after finishing season two: why its divided lives, performances and unsettling office made me rate it more highly.
Read review